Partner content by David Schissler, Executive Director, MSCI.

Private-market investing has always required judgement. An investment team considering a new fund commitment may spend weeks assessing a manager's strategy, track record, team, portfolio construction and terms before deciding whether the opportunity merits capital.

That work remains fundamental, but for family offices with increasingly complex portfolios, there is another question that deserves equal attention: even if this is an attractive investment, is it the right investment for the portfolio we already own?

A new commitment does not enter an empty portfolio. It enters one that may already contain private funds, direct investments, public securities, real assets and cash, potentially held across multiple entities and for different beneficiaries. Understanding the opportunity is therefore only part of the decision. The investment team also needs to understand what adding it could change.

From investment analysis to portfolio decisions

For family offices making their own private-market commitments, the first task remains understanding the investment itself. Private-market diligence can be demanding, with information on strategy, historical performance, underlying investments, key people, terms and governance spread across General Partner (GP) documents and presented in different formats.

Technology can bring greater structure to this process, organizing information more consistently and allowing funds, managers and vintages to be compared more systematically.

But a strong manager or attractive strategy does not automatically make an investment right for a particular portfolio.

The more consequential analysis begins when the prospective investment is considered alongside the assets already held. What exposures would it add? Where might it increase an existing concentration? How could it affect the portfolio's risk profile? What would different commitment sizes mean for future liquidity? Would another investment provide a better fit?

These are questions that can inform the decision before capital is committed.

The same exposure can appear in different places

Portfolios are usually organized into categories because categories are useful. Public equity, private equity, venture capital, private credit, real estate and infrastructure have different characteristics and require different expertise.

Economic exposures, however, do not necessarily observe those boundaries.

A family office could have exposure to similar companies, sectors, geographies or risk factors through several different vehicles. A technology exposure may appear directly in a public equity portfolio, indirectly through a private equity fund and again through a venture investment. Viewed separately, each allocation may appear reasonable. Viewed together, the concentration may look different.

This is where a total-portfolio perspective can support better decisions. Rather than asking only whether there is room within a private-equity allocation for another fund, an investment team can examine the underlying exposures already present across public and private holdings and consider what the proposed investment would add.

A consistent analytical view across public and private assets can also make it possible to test alternatives before acting. A family office might compare different commitment sizes, consider one strategy against another or assess how a proposed allocation could alter concentration and risk across the portfolio.

The objective is not simply to see the portfolio more clearly. It is to use that visibility to make a better-informed decision about what to do next.

A commitment is also a liquidity decision

The same principle applies to liquidity. Committing capital and deploying capital are not the same event.

A commitment made today may generate capital calls over several years, while the timing and scale of distributions from existing investments remain uncertain. At the same time, the family may have operating expenses, tax obligations, planned acquisitions, philanthropic commitments or requirements from beneficiaries drawing on the same pool of available liquidity.

The relevant question is therefore not simply whether the family has enough cash to make a commitment today, but how that commitment could affect its ability to meet a range of obligations tomorrow.

Analytics can help investment teams explore that uncertainty rather than rely on a single forecast. Different assumptions for capital calls, distributions, market conditions or new commitments can be modelled to understand how the portfolio and its liquidity position could evolve under a range of scenarios.

That analysis can influence decisions today: whether to make a commitment, how large it should be, whether another allocation needs to change, or how much liquidity should be retained elsewhere in the portfolio.

The aim is not to predict precisely what will happen. Private-market cash flows will always contain uncertainty. The aim is to understand the range of plausible outcomes and make decisions with those trade-offs visible.

Making the portfolio part of the investment decision

For many investment teams, information about a prospective manager and analysis of the existing portfolio have traditionally sat in separate processes. Bringing them closer together creates an opportunity to move beyond looking backwards at what the portfolio has done and towards analysing what it could look like under different decisions.

MSCI's Total Plan Manager is designed to support that type of total-portfolio analysis, bringing public and private investments together so investors can assess exposures, risk and liquidity and model the potential effects of transactions, commitments and future cash flows.

For family offices undertaking their own private-market manager selection, the MSCI Diligence Platform can complement that analysis by structuring information from GP documents to support more consistent comparison and diligence across funds and managers.

The point is not to replace investment judgement with analytics. It is to give that judgement more context.

Before making the next private-market commitment, an investment team can consider not only the quality of the opportunity, but the exposures it could add, the concentrations it could increase, the liquidity it could require and the alternatives available.

For family offices managing increasingly complex combinations of public and private wealth, the value of a total-portfolio view is therefore not simply knowing more about what they own. It is being better equipped to decide what to do next.

-

About MSCI

MSCI Inc. (NYSE: MSCI ) strengthens global markets by connecting participants across the financial ecosystem with a common language. Our research-based data, analytics and indexes, supported by advanced technology, set standards for global investors and help our clients understand risks and opportunities so they can make better decisions and unlock innovation. We serve asset managers and owners, private-market sponsors and investors, hedge funds, wealth managers, banks, insurers and corporates. To learn more, please visit www.msci.com

Disclaimer

The data, data feeds, databases, reports, text, graphs, charts, images, videos, recordings, models, metrics, analytics, indexes, assessments, ratings, scores, software, websites, products, services and other information delivered in connection with this notice (the “Information”): (a) are proprietary information of MSCI and its suppliers, (b) may not be used for commercial purposes without prior written permission from MSCI Inc. or its affiliates (“MSCI”), and (c) are not investment advice and must not be relied on as such. The Information and its use are further subject to the disclaimer at https://www.msci.com/legal/notice-and-disclaimer. As detailed therein, MSCI AND ITS SUPPLIERS MAKE NO EXPRESS OR IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE OR OTHERWISE WITH RESPECT TO THE INFORMATION HEREIN AND DISCLAIM ALL LIABILITY TO THE MAXIMUM EXTENT PERMITTED BY LAW. For information about how MSCI collects and uses personal data, refer to https://www.msci.com/privacy-pledge.