By Bryce Webster, founder of CIO Family Office.

I wrote a recent article about the attractive opportunity in real estate, given that we are coming out of a significant real estate recession in 2022-2024 and real estate fundamentals are now improving. Supply and demand are coming back into balance in multiple sectors, including multifamily and single-family rental. Occupancy is edging higher, concessions are burning off, and rent growth is in the bottoming process.

I believe that rent growth will re-accelerate over the next couple of years, a positive inflection from the declining or flat rent growth in the recent past. Meanwhile, prices are low or reasonable, which makes for a good setup.

I touched on interest rates in this piece, indicating that they are recently on the rise. The 5-year Treasury yield is currently 4.90%, up from about 4.40% in late August (3 months ago). This is a significant move that warrants addressing. If interest rates stay at these elevated levels, there will be upward pressure on cap rates. However, it takes time for the market to adjust. Initially, sellers want to sell at yesterday's price, while buyers want a discount due to rising rates. Eventually this tension resolves in favor of either buyers or sellers.

There is an interesting comparison between private real estate and public REITs. They have exposure to the same underlying asset, but public REITs trade daily and incorporate news almost instantly, while the private market takes time to adjust to changes.

The public market discounts the next 12 months, incorporating future scenarios into the stock price today. While the public market is not always right and sometimes overshoots, it always has a view.

Valuation

Private market real estate is valued by doing a pro forma cash flow analysis, where you project out cash flows for 3-5 years and assume a sale value at the end. Then you calculate an IRR and determine a projected return over the hold period. The required return for real estate fluctuates over time and is different for each property, but is determined by base interest rates plus a risk premium for the asset.

Public market REITs tend to trade on AFFO multiples, dividend yields, and implied cap rates. AFFO (adjusted funds from operations) is a proxy for free cash flow. The AFFO multiple is the share price divided by AFFO per share. This is comparable to a P/E multiple for the broader stock market. The implied cap rate is calculated as the net operating income from the REIT divided by the enterprise value. This changes as the stock price moves up and down, and is a proxy for comparing against private market cap rates.

Since public REITs discount the next 12 months, the implied cap rate is essentially where the market collectively believes that cap rates are headed a year from now. When investors are cautious, implied cap rates move higher, resulting in a positive spread to private market cap rates.

This is the case today, particularly for residential REITs. While private market cap rates for apartments and single-family rentals are in the mid 5% area, REIT implied cap rates are 6%-7%. This valuation disconnect can persist for a long period of time, but eventually tends to converge. Either public REITs move up and implied cap rates come down, private market cap rates move up, or a combination of both.

What is the opportunity?

Right now, I believe the opportunity is in public market REITs with a multi-year hold.

As interest rates have moved higher, public REITs have reacted in real time and traded lower. Meanwhile, the private market has not yet reacted. This has resulted in a big disconnect between public and private. I expect that private transaction volume will slow, as the market determines a new market price.

Though interest rates are front and center today, over longer periods of time interest rates are a less reliable predictor of REIT returns. Rather, fundamental factors like revenue and NOI growth are the main drivers, which I believe are at a positive inflection point.

Private framework for public REITs

I think it is useful to apply the pro forma analysis in private real estate to public REITs. To do this we assume the purchase price is based on the current stock price, which translates to market cap and enterprise value. Then, we can make some assumptions for NOI growth over the hold period, and assume an exit cap rate at the end.

As an example, I performed this analysis for Invitation Homes (INVH) and show a summary below:

I assume that this year (2026) is period 0 in the analysis, and the hold period is 3 years (2027-2029). I start with 2026 NOI growth per company guidance, and then make some assumptions about NOI growth over the next few years. I assume an exit cap rate (6.25%) that is higher than private market cap rates today, but lower than the current implied cap rate for the stock (7.00%).

The reason for this is twofold: (1) as NOI growth returns, there will be downward pressure on cap rates and (2) there’s a reasonable chance that public market implied cap rates have overshot the top.

This results in an IRR over 3 years of approximately 16%. I then remove the REIT G&A (similar to management fees for a private real estate deal) to get to a net IRR of about 15%. This is a solid absolute return, and is around the level that I look for in private real estate deals.

Another factor to consider is that leverage is lower for public REITs, at roughly 30% Debt/Enterprise Value vs 60%-70% for private real estate, which improves the risk-adjusted return for REITs. Below is a sensitivity analysis of the net IRR at various cap rates. Even if the exit cap rate is 7.00% in 3 years, the net return is about 10%, a very respectable return.

This is just one REIT I’ve picked to show as an example, though I am currently focused on the public REIT sector more broadly in search of opportunities.

-

Bryce Webster, CFA, is the founder of CIO Family Office, where he serves as an outsourced CIO for family offices. He has 20 years of investment experience, including 15 years in institutional real estate. A Cornell graduate with an MBA from NYU Stern, he writes at ciofamilyoffice.substack.com.

Important disclosures

This post reflects the author’s personal views as of the date published and is for general informational and educational purposes only. It is not investment, legal, or tax advice, is not personalized to any reader’s situation, and is not an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any security or interest in any fund or private offering. Reading this newsletter or contacting the author does not create an advisory, fiduciary, or client relationship. Companies, sectors, managers, and transactions are referenced as illustrations only, not as recommendations.

The author advises family offices for compensation. The author, his clients, and their affiliates may hold positions in or have business relationships with anything discussed, and those positions may change without notice. The author receives no third-party compensation for this content. Views are his own and not those of any client or affiliated entity.

Information comes from third-party sources believed reliable but is not guaranteed or independently verified. Projections and estimates are inherently uncertain; actual results may differ materially. Views are subject to change and will not be updated. All investing involves risk of loss, and past performance does not guarantee future results. Private investments carry added risks including illiquidity, leverage, and potential total loss.